Invalid Input

Invalid Input

Search the Remnant Newspaper
Sunday, September 30, 2018

QUANDARIES & BLACK HILLS: Keeping the Old Faith

Rate this item
(21 votes)
We've got  to keep on keeping on. - Michael J. Matt We've got to keep on keeping on. - Michael J. Matt

Editor's Note: The following non-controversial change of pace appeared a few months ago in the print edition of The Remnant.  I'm reproducing it here as a little breather, and also as a reminder to non-subscribing visitors to our site that The Remnant is not at all single issue. We’re committed to providing reading material on family life, raising kids, lives of the saints and all the wonderful things that even in this bizarre day and age help to keep us all grounded and mindful of who we are and why God put on this earth. Yes, things are not good right now, but our job as followers of Jesus Christ remains the same: Regardless of what Pope Francis is up to, we need to get up every morning, say our prayers, raise our kids, love our wives, do our duty, laugh, pray and support each other wherever we happen to find one another here behind these enemy lines. If you're not already a subscriber to The Remnant, perhaps you'd consider at least subscribing to our E-edition so that you can have access to all the work we do, much of which is completely non-polemical and strives to just gently confirm the brethren living in a world at war with God. I hope you'll join us. MJM 

Yesterday your old editor climbed Mount Quandary—the highest summit of the Tenmile Range in the Rocky Mountains of North America. I’m not getting any younger, and so climbing the 14,200-foot mountain with my son, his cousins and a couple of brothers-in-law was considerably more challenging than I’d anticipated. There were points, in fact, when I mentally took on the task in increments of ten feet: “Okay, I can do the next ten. We’ll see about the rest later.”

For three hours this went on, until at last we made the cold and windy summit, looking out over a field of snow-capped mountaintops that couldn’t not inspire thoughts of the truly awesome glory of God and His creation. Say what you will about America and her many problems, her natural beauty is unsurpassed anywhere on earth:

After a few moments of happy and exhausted celebration (see video), it dawned on me that we still had to get back down the mountain—a task that turned out to be nearly as challenging as getting up. But down we went, some (read: this writer) more slowly than others.

The next day, I found myself crossing a much flatter surface, this time whiteknuckling it in a van along a piece of desolate highway on another planet called the Great Plains States.

Riding an endless ribbon of blacktop that bravely cuts a narrow swath through the no-man’s-land from Colorado to South Dakota, I found myself bemused by the thought of “experts” telling us we have an overpopulation problem in this country. All the men and women on earth could live in the land we crossed that day, with plenty of room to spare. The sheer desolation of places like northern Nebraska makes it so that even a lone tree standing antisocially along the side of the highway becomes something to see and take note of.

As we raced along, we were strangely comforted by the sight of an occasional heard of cattle, gathered together along the highway, trying to prevent the 100-degree heat from turning them into barbequed steaks. We nodded to them as we passed, happy to briefly have their company.

This article first appeared in The Remnant Newspaper. Get access to exclusive newspaper features--Subscribe Today!
new subscribe newspaper ad

The vast emptiness went on forever, your editor rather desperately clinging to the steering wheel at times, his sleeping children stacked like cordwood in the rearview mirror providing a sober reminder to keep it between the lines.

Finally, the daunting nothingness turned into something: a pretty little place called Rapid City, South Dakota—the Black Hills, the Badlands, Crazy Horse, and Mount Rushmore. We’d made the halfway point.

Lovely to look at, to be sure, but this was Sunday and we needed to go to Mass.

Surely, we’d never find a Traditional Latin Mass out here!

But South Dakota is not without its surprises. Years ago, I remember running into the great, great, great, great grandson of the Sioux Chief Sitting Bull and being pleasantly surprised when he told me that he’s actually a devout Christian, and so are many in his tribe.

Not only Sitting Bull, but many of the Native Americans at the Battle of Little Big Horn, were, in fact, Catholics, having been introduced to the Faith and then baptized by Catholic priests such the great Jesuit missionary Pierre-Jean De Smet.

Father De Smet was a traditional Catholic, of course, having spent his priestly life offering the Traditional Latin Mass every day. But that was a long time ago and we were traveling in the Wild West of Vatican II.

With a little help from Google, we found a possible option and a short while later pulled into the parking lot of the Immaculate Conception Church in Rapid City, South Dakota: 


With our seven children in tow, my wife and I entered through the rear doors of the church, only to be confronted by a familiar sight—dozens of small children crawling around on the floor, clinging to their mothers’ knees, haphazardly veiled, in little skirts and ties—trying manfully to keep quiet.

I noticed a plaque on the wall, indicating that the old church is protected by the historical society. Thus, the beautifully preserved interior, high alar, patient statues, original stained glass, communion rail, etc. The Modernist marauders had obviously been barred at the door, Deo Gratias.

As we made our way to one of the very few open pews, I could hear the old wooden floor creaking beneath my feet, and I was immediately brought back in time to the old framed country churches I’d known as a boy. I half expected to hear the telltale squeaking of an old pump organ’s bellows as I took my place.

It was a hot day, and the doors of the church had been propped open to let a warm South Dakota breeze do what it could to keep the congregation comfortable.

I saw farmers, old and young.

Newlyweds, grandmothers and grandfathers, and children… large families, so many dresses, so many veils.

The time machine was working just fine.

At the altar a young priest, Father Christopher Hathaway, FSSP, was beginning the Prayers at the Foot of the Altar and my children quickly filled the empty pew, each one—even the youngest, Michael (6)—knowing exactly what to do: lower the old clunky kneeler and assume the position. It was, after all, the very same Mass they’ve been attending all their lives.

We may have been in far off South Dakota, but the children were right at home in this church, which positively breathed traditional Catholic ambience.

It was low Mass with hymns, and the choir was so reminiscent of those I’d known in my youth—devout, prayerful, not perfect but not pretentious, either; just dedicated parishioners, faithfully manning the loft every Sunday out of love for God and old Latin Mass. It was easy to pray as they sang the familiar old hymns of years past.

The sermon was simple yet profoundly pastoral. Again, nothing pretentious and not too long, either—just the patient lesson of a loving father, teaching his children how to be chaste, how to be Catholic, how to get to heaven. Its catechetical simplicity engaged my children immediately.

Familiar old hymns, chapel veils, fussing babies, stain glass-filtered light and the murmur of Latin—this place was home and these people, family. I knew them all, though we’d never met.

The breeze picked up, and the consecration began, and I felt that same safe and Catholic peace I’d always experience as a boy in little churches likes these. God was coming down, kneel up straight.

As we made our way to the parking lot after Mass, I was happy to bump into a man named Gary Velder (see photo), whom I’d never met but I instantly knew and liked. Gary is from the old days. I met him a thousand times before. He was always talking to my father after Mass when I was a kid.

I’d know Gary anywhere—he’s one of the traditional Catholic pioneers, the old Catholic folks who were “traddie” before “traddie” was cool. He’d been in the trenches all his life, too—holding fast to the old days and the old ways. His ready, affable smile gave away that Catholic optimism that had always been the mark of the ‘old soldiers’: “Christ wins in the end, right? All we’ve got to do is stick with Him, which means holding fast to Tradition. We got this!”

Mike and GaryMichael Matt and Gary, "old" friends

We talked for a few moments, Gary and I, and soon realized we had pretty much the same stories to tell—memories of the old days, the hotel Masses, the “roamin’ Catholics”. Gary had been there, too, all those years ago…and he remembers what it was like when the whole world thought we were crazy. Not so much anymore.

Here we were, having just attended the “outlawed” Traditional Latin Mass, celebrated by a young priest in an historic church filled with babies and large Catholic families.

Take that, Vatican II!

In the few moments we were together, Gary and I smiled a lot. It’s been a long haul, but God is good. It was like two seasoned soldiers chatting briefly behind the frontline. It went without saying that they’d taken most of our churches, but they never managed to take our faith— and they never will.

Gary told me that he and his wife, Linda, sometimes attend the Latin Mass at St. Joseph Catholic Church in Spearfish, South Dakota, as well. So, they have TLM options way out there in the badlands. Who would’ve thought!

Father Hathaway has been offering the Latin Mass out there for ten years, and Gary told me the community is growing rapidly in Rapid City—a happy reality I’d just witnessed firsthand; the church was packed out.

He didn’t say, but I’ll bet Gary never thought he’d live to see the day when the old Mass would return like this. I know I never did. And yet here it is, not only surviving but thriving even in the most unlikely places.

Standing outside the little, old church in South Dakota, talking to Gary, I thought of Michael Davies and my father and all the pioneers who didn’t quite live long enough to see the fruits of their labors, but who never lost hope in the Providence of a good God. They must be smiling now.

There’s still so much work to be done, but the return of the old Latin Mass— touchstone of the Old Faith—to so many places in the world today should surely give us all the hope we need to continue on and to persevere in the good fight. God has not abandoned us. He’s not left us orphans. For a while there it seemed like maybe He had. But, no, He was there all along, just sleeping in the boat.

As I said goodbye to Gary, my thoughts returned to the mountain in Colorado that from the ground had looked positively insurmountable. But it turned out not to be. It just looked that way. It was an optical illusion. All we had to do was keep putting one foot in front of the other, confident that the summit was waiting for us just above the clouds.

It's not easy being Catholic right now. We've got problems, lots of them. But we've got to keep going, lift our eyes to the hills, never give up, and in a little while we’ll all meet merrily at the top, content with the knowledge that we did our best to do what our fathers had taught us to do and what God wants of us…nothing more, nothing less.

We’re no heroes. We’re just Catholics trying to get over the mountain.

Keep the Old Faith, and we'll see you at the summit.

[Comment Guidelines - Click to view]
Last modified on Monday, October 1, 2018
Michael J. Matt | Editor

Michael J. Matt has been an editor of The Remnant since 1990. Since 1994, he has been the newspaper's editor. A graduate of Christendom College, Michael Matt has written hundreds of articles on the state of the Church and the modern world. He is the host of The Remnant Underground and Remnant TV's The Remnant Forum. He's been U.S. Coordinator for Notre Dame de Chrétienté in Paris--the organization responsible for the Pentecost Pilgrimage to Chartres, France--since 2000.  Mr. Matt has led the U.S. contingent on the Pilgrimage to Chartres for the last 24 years. He is a lecturer for the Roman Forum's Summer Symposium in Gardone Riviera, Italy. He is the author of Christian Fables, Legends of Christmas and Gods of Wasteland (Fifty Years of Rock ‘n’ Roll) and regularly delivers addresses and conferences to Catholic groups about the Mass, home-schooling, and the culture question. Together with his wife, Carol Lynn and their seven children, Mr. Matt currently resides in St. Paul, Minnesota.