What most people don’t realize about Gosnell is that he was a prince amongst abortionists, belying the usual bottom-feeder image, which is typically accurate. Gosnell was a stellar medical student – unlike, say, Willie Parker. Gosnell was also a highly-cultured character – a fine pianist, for example, and a free verse poet of some distinction. I don’t know whether a piano is available in prison. I think he’s still publishing poems.
On exposure, arrest, and conviction, Gosnell was excoriated by his fellow abortionists. Pioneers are always treated this way by those who lag behind. Why, I asked myself at the time, are Gosnell’s acts even an issue? They’re only crimes because of fine distinctions made in the law. They’re not essentially different than what other abortionists do. And, ethically, they’re no different from what many abortion supporters do. Whoever consents to pay for an abortion is himself, as far as moral responsibility goes, an abortionist.
Which brings me to my point.
In the last presidential election season, there was a highly-visible movement to get pro-lifers to back Joe Biden, on the grounds that Trump was and is beyond the pale. Some of this was simply tendentious redefinition of what it means to be pro-life. Can a candidate be truly pro-life, in the broad sense favored by such creatures, if he opposes taxpayer-funded surgical transitions for bored crossdressers in state correctional facilities? Certainly not! But some of those pushing Biden actually professed to be pro-life according to the definition established by usage. They claimed to oppose abortion. Jimmy Martin, S.J., is in this category. He even spoke in support of Biden at the Democrat convention.
Thing is that Biden’s platform, adopted to mollify any resistance from Bernie Saunders and AOC, included abolition of the Hyde Amendment and taxpayer funding of abortions at all stages. Now that enough mail-in ballots have been found to turn Georgia’s U.S. Senate delegation a bright pro-abortion blue, this promise to the abortion lobby is more than likely to come true all across America. Biden has already made it a feature of Yankee global outreach – with an executive order abolishing the Mexico City policy. Hurray for broad pro-life principles!
Please let me put these unruly ducks in order. Biden said he was going to use federal funds to pay for abortions. As he pledged, Biden is using federal funds to pay for abortions – overseas for now, but very soon right here in the Unified States of Democrat America. Taxpayers are paying for abortions now and will soon be paying for many more. I’m a taxpayer – so I’m paying for abortions. But I’m paying for them unwillingly, despite strenuous objections, at the point, as Lysander Spooner might say, of a bayonet. The force implicit in making me pay for abortions is emphasized, at least in my eyes, by the continuing National Guard occupation of Washington, D.C. Do our soldiers still have bayonets at the ends of their rifles?
If they are taxpayers, members of the broad pro-life crowd (mostly Catholic bloggers and commentators) are, like me, paying for abortions – but, unlike me, they are not paying at the point of a bayonet. They voted for the Biden/Harris pro-abortion governmental axis. Father Jimmy, S.J., is not at the point of a bayonet. Pretend poetess Rebecca Bratten-Weiss is not at the point of a bayonet. Ponderous semi-literate poseur Mark Shea is not at the point of a bayonet. Shea acolyte Scott Eric Alt is not at the point of a bayonet. Deacon Steve Greydanus, who enjoys pederastic coming-of-age flicks starring Armie Hammer, is not at the point of a bayonet. “Public Catholic” Rebecca Hamilton is not at the point of a bayonet. Self-pitying, sentimental pontificatrix Mary Pezzulo is not at the point of a bayonet. (In fairness to the Pezzulo, she probably doesn’t pay federal taxes.) No one in this mob is at the point of a bayonet. They were told in advance that a vote for Biden meant taxpayers would pay for abortions. Biden is merely keeping his word to them. With their votes, they consented to pay for abortions – and not just for a few.
Remember the rule. Ethically, if you consent to pay for abortions, you are yourself an abortionist. Father Jimmy and his merry crew are now big-time abortionists.
Now I know how these operators will try to squirm out of responsibility for their votes. They’ll say their “cooperation” with Biden’s taxpayer-funded abortions is too “remote” to constitute a culpable action. Mark Shea in particular says this sort of thing all the time. His very belches, replete with donut gluttony, become remote the moment they foul the air. But Shea and his fellow eager funders of the abortion regime are wrong here. It is my cooperation with the regime that is remote. I’m merely paying taxes in order to avoid that super-scary IRS bayonet. But the votes of Jimmy Martin, Mark Shea, and Rebecca Bratten-Weiss were not remote actions. They were the consequences of deliberate decision. The broad pro-lifers consented. It’s their consent that makes them abortionists, not the mere destination of the dollars that the federal government under Biden extorts from them.
Even more absurdly, these clownish abortionists without medical degrees – quintessential back-alley abortionists – will protest that they didn’t vote for Biden because he was going to fund abortions with their tax dollars. No, no! They had other reasons, really good reasons, broad pro-life reasons, to vote for Biden. Kids in cages! Confederate statues and flags! Trump’s tweets! Rebecca Hamilton wrote a whole post about the pride she took in voting for Biden – because she was voting against Hitler! Yes, with her vote, Hamilton was storming the beaches at Normandy. Wasn’t that brave and noble of her?
None of this blather matters in the least, even if you acknowledge the benevolence of the reasons stated. Hey, Hamlet! I didn’t kill your father because I wanted him dead! I only wanted to be king and marry your mom! Hey, Duncan! Nothing personal. I was just following the path that the Weird Sisters laid out for me! Claudius still consented to the murder of Hamlet the Elder. Macbeth still consented to the murder of Duncan. And the broad pro-lifers still consented to pay for abortions.
They are all exactly as guilty as Kermit Gosnell. All they lack is his status as med school star. Oh, and his cultural achievements.
I understand that Scott Eric Alt plays the piano. Maybe he and Gosnell can take turns on the keyboard where they’re headed. Once again, I don’t know whether a piano will be provided.